A Review of Studies on German International Relations in 20th Century

Abstract

Abstract: Due to certain social historical conditions,the studies of modern International Relations in Germany had comparatively started late.Although there has not been an independent German IR school,the experience of IR studies in 20th century with German characteristics plays a significant role in the development of western IR discipline.Based on investigating the historical development of German IR discipline,the authors systematically run through major schools of German IR studies and elaborately analyze their features.

Key words: German International Relations, Geopolitics, the Frankfort School, International Regimes, European integration

摘要： 由于特定的社会历史条件,现代国际关系研究在德国起步较晚,也始终未成独立学派,但20世纪具有德国特色的国际关系研究经验对西方国际关系学科的发展发挥了重要的作用。本文在考察德国国际关系学科发展历史脉络的基础上,系统地梳理了德国国际关系研究的主要流派,并对其特点进行了详尽分析。

关键词: 德国国际关系, 地缘政治学, 法兰克福学派, 国际机制, 欧洲一体化

CLC Number:

D819

WU Zhi-cheng, ZHAO Jing-jing. A Review of Studies on German International Relations in 20th Century[J]. Teaching and Research, 2010, (8): 56-64.

吴志成, 赵晶晶. 20世纪德国的国际关系研究评析[J]. 《教学与研究》, 2010, (8): 56-64.

References

[1] A.J.R.格鲁姆.国际关系学:从不仅仅是一门美国的社会科学[J].欧洲研究,2006,(3).
[2] 钮菊生,郭树勇.试论法兰克福学派对国际政治理论的影响[J].世界经济与政治,2003,(9).
[3] 熊炜.德国特色的国际关系学:借鉴、创新与启示[J].世界经济与政治,2009,(7).
[4] Ulrich Albrecht.The Study of International Relations in the Federal Republic of Germany[A].In Hugh.C.Dyer,Leon Mangasarian (eds.).The Study of International Relations-The state of the Art[C].The Macmillan Press LTD,1989.
[5] Karl Kaiser,Hans-Peter Schwarz,Hrsg.Weltpolitik im neuen Jahrhundert[M].Bonn:Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung,2000; Wichard Woyke,Hrsg.Handwoerterbuch Intemationale Politik[M].Bonn..Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung,2000.
[6] Gunther Hellmann,Klaus Dieter Wolf,Michael Zürn (eds.).Die neuen Internationalen Beziehungen.Forschungsstand und Perspektiven in Deutschland[C].Baden-Baden..Nomos Verlagsgesellschaft,2003.
[7] Gerard Holden.The state of the art in German IR[J].Review of International Studies,Vol.30,2004.
[8] Knud Erik Jorgensen.Continental IR Theory:The Best Kept Secret[J].European Journal of International Relations,Vol.6,No.1,2000.
[9] 袁正清.交往行为理论与国际政治研究——以德国国际关系研究视角为中心的一项考察[J].世界经济与政治,2006,(9).
[10] Ole Wever.The Sociology of a Not So International Discipline:American and European Development in International Relations[J].International Organization,Vol.52,No.4,1998.
[11] Leon Mangasarian.Im Osten Nichts Neues?International Studies in the German Democratic Republic[A].in Hugh.C.Dyer,Leon Mangasarian (eds.).The Study of International Relations-the state of the Art[C].The Macmillan Press LTD,1989.
[12] Wilhelm Bruns.Die AuBenpolitik der DDR[M].Berlin:Colloquium Verlag,1985.
[13] 杰弗里·帕克.二十世纪的西方地理政治思想[M].北京:解放军出版社,1992.
[14] Robert Strausz-Hupe.Geopolitics:The Struggle for Space and Power[M].New York:Putnam's,1942.
[15] C.E.Zoppo,C.Zorgbibe(eds.).On Geopolitics:Classical and Nuclear[C].the Netherlands:Marinus Nijhoff,1985.
[16] 萧俊明.关于法兰克福学派批判理论的重新思考[J].国外社会科学,2001,(1).
[17] Scott Burchill,Andrew Linklater.Theories of International Relations[M].London:MacMillian Press,1996.
[18] Jürgen Habermas.Between Norms and Facts:Contributions to a Discourse Theory of Law and Democracy[M].The MIT Press.1998.
[19] Thomas Risse.Let's Argue! Communicative Action in World Politics[J].International Organization,Vol.54,No.1,2000.
[20] 黄瑞祺.社会理论和社会世界[M].北京:北京大学出版社,2005.
[21] Richard K.Ashley.Political Realism and Human Interests[J].International Studies Quarterly,Vol.25,No.2,1981.
[22] Alastair J.H.Murray.Reconstructing Realism[M].Kiel University Press,1997.
[23] Thomas Risse,Stephen Ropp,Kathryn Sikkink (eds.).The Power of Human Rights:International Norms and Domestic Change[M].Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.1999; Helen Wallace,Willian Wallace,Mark A.Polack.Policy-Making in the European Union[M].Oxford:Oxford University Press.2005.
[24] Herald Müller.Arguing,Bargaining and All That:Communicative Action,Rationalist Theory and the Logic of Appropriateness in International Relations[J].European Journal of International Relations,Vol.10,No.3,2004.
[25] Herald Müller.International Relations as Communicative Action[A].in Karin M.Frank,Knud Erik Jorgensen(eds.).Constructing International Relations:the next generation[C].New York:M.E.Sharpe,2001.
[26] Volker Rittberger (ed.).Regime Theory and International Regime[C].Oxford:Clarendon Press,1993.
[27] A.基尔萨诺夫.美国与西欧:第二次世界大战后的经济关系[M].北京:商务印书馆,1978.
[28] 杨寿国.阿登纳传[M].上海:上海外语教育出版社,1992.
[29] 维利·勃兰特.会见与思考[M].北京:商务印书馆,1979.
[30] 黄正柏.阿登纳的欧洲联合政策及早期实施——兼谈德国对二战的反思[J].世界历史,1997,(1).
[31] 康拉德·阿登纳.阿登纳回忆录(一)[M].上海:上海人民出版社,1976.
[32] 吕耀坤.德国与欧洲一体化[J].德国研究,1998,(3).
[33] 刘立群.德法对欧洲一体化目标之争评析[J].德国研究,2001,(3).
[34] Thomas Risse-Keppen.Exploring the Nature of the Beast:International Relations Theory and Comparative Policy Analysis Meet the European Union[J].Journal of Common Market Studies,Vol.34,No.1,1996.
[35] Thomas Risse.U.S.Power in a Liberal Security Community,America Unrivalled:the Future of the Balance of Power[M].Ithaca:Cornell University Press,2002.
[36] Beate Kohler-Koch,Rainer Eising (eds.).The Transformation of Governance in the European Union[C].London:Routledge,1999.
[37] Ciaran Cronin,Pablo de Greiff (eds.).The Inclusion of the Other:Studies in Political Theory[C].Cambridge:Polity Press,1999.
[38] Frederic H.Gareau.The Discipline of International Relations:A Multi-National Perspective[J].Journal of Politics,Vol.43,No.3,1981.