为新兴右翼保守派量身定做的民粹主义概念——对米勒民粹主义理论的批评

教学与研究 ›› 2021, Vol. 55 ›› Issue (2): 100-108.

为新兴右翼保守派量身定做的民粹主义概念——对米勒民粹主义理论的批评

中国政法大学政治与公共管理学院

出版日期:2021-02-16 发布日期:2021-01-18
作者简介:丛日云，中国政法大学政治与公共管理学院教授（北京 102249）。

A Tailored Populist Concept for Emerging RightWing Conservatives——A Critique of Müller's Populism Theory

School of Politics and Public Administration, China University of Political Science and Law, Beijing 102249, China

Online:2021-02-16 Published:2021-01-18

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 米勒将学界通常认定的欧美左翼民粹排除在民粹主义之外，为新兴的右翼保守派量身定做了民粹主义标签，而新兴的右翼保守派恰是主流（左翼）民粹的对立面，这使米勒的定义充满了混乱。他通过排除法否定了学界通常认定的若干民粹主义的标准特征，力图找到判定民粹主义的统一的和独一的标准，但他通过这个方法得到的高度窄化了的民粹主义定义仍然是与其他政治思潮交叉的，而他对这个定义的经验证明则是脱靶的和混乱的。他对左翼民粹的同情和支持说明他本人正是一个民粹主义者。

关键词: 民粹主义, 保守主义, 扬维尔纳·米勒

Abstract: Müller's definition of populism is fraught with confusion by excluding what scholars typically identify as leftwing populism in Europe and the United States, and the populist label tailored for the emerging rightwing conservatives who are the very antithesis of mainstream (leftwing) populism. He endeavored to find a unified and unique criterion of populism and negates some standard features frequently used by academic circles through the exclusion method. However, the highly narrowed definition of populism that he obtained by this method remained to intersect with other political thoughts, and his empirical evidence for this definition was still disordered. Moreover, his sympathy and support to the leftwing populism that manifests he is a populist accurately.

Key words: populism, conservatism, JanWerner Müller

丛日云. 为新兴右翼保守派量身定做的民粹主义概念——对米勒民粹主义理论的批评[J]. 教学与研究, 2021, 55(2): 100-108.

Cong Riyun. A Tailored Populist Concept for Emerging RightWing Conservatives——A Critique of Müller's Populism Theory[J]. Teaching and Research, 2021, 55(2): 100-108.

[1]	葛浩阳. 积累的社会结构理论视角下资本主义民主政治再考察——基于西方“民主失灵”现状的理论分析[J]. 教学与研究, 2021, 55(8): 87-96.
[2]	王奎，胡树祥. 网络民粹主义辨析[J]. 《教学与研究》, 2020, 54(5): 36-42.
[3]	赵司空. 东欧共产主义怀旧的症候分析[J]. 《教学与研究》, 2018, 52(11): 81-87.
[4]	田野. 全球化、要素禀赋和政党重组——对欧洲民粹主义浪潮的一项解释[J]. 《教学与研究》, 2018, 52(10): 43-54.
[5]	程恩富，张奕阳. 民粹主义的理论与现实辨析[J]. 《教学与研究》, 2017, 51(11): 5-13.
[6]	左玉河. 孙中山民生主义思想中的民粹主义倾向[J]. 《教学与研究》, 2016, 50(10): 13-19.
[7]	刘永涛. 茶党运动与重铸美国极端保守主义[J]. 《教学与研究》, 2013, 47(9): 55-63.
[8]	陈超. 新保守主义与美国全球民主化战略[J]. 《教学与研究》, 2003, (9): 58-63.
[9]	李毅. 文化保守主义的哲学观及其实质[J]. 《教学与研究》, 2001, (11): 36-41.