主管:教育部
主办:中国人民大学
ISSN 0257-2826  CN 11-1454/G4

《教学与研究》 ›› 2005, Vol. ›› Issue (5): 42-48.DOI:

• 学术评论 • 上一篇    下一篇

质疑“马恩对立论”

赵家祥   

  1. 北京大学, 邓小平理论研究中心, 北京, 100871
  • 收稿日期:2005-02-25 出版日期:2005-05-20 发布日期:2012-03-05

Doubt on “Conflicts between Marx and Engles”

ZHAO Jia-xiang   

  1. Research Center of Deng Xiaoping Theory, Peking University, Beijing 100871, China
  • Received:2005-02-25 Online:2005-05-20 Published:2012-03-05

摘要: 国内外理论界都有人认为,马克思的哲学与恩格斯的哲学不仅是有差别的,而且是对立的,这种对立主要表现在以下两个方面:(1)在人类社会与自然界的关系问题上,马克思主张人类社会与自然界的统一,恩格斯则主张人类社会与自然界的二元对立;(2)在历史发展的主体性与客观性的关系问题上,马克思强调人的活动的重要性,恩格斯则片面强调遵循客观规律的重要性,是机械决定论。作者以马克思、恩格斯的文本为依据,从以上两个方面论证了马克思、恩格斯的哲学在本质上是相同的,“马恩对立论”是虚构的、不能成立的。文章还从马克思、恩格斯共同创立和详细阐发他们的理论的过程方面,论述了二人思想的基本一致性。

关键词: 马克思, 恩格斯, 差别, 对立, 相同

Abstract: Some scholars both at home and abroad hold that there exist not only differences but also conflicts between Marx and Engels. They have identified two conflicts. First, on the relation between human society and nature, Marx provokes unity of the two, while Engels maintains that human society and nature are conflicting. Second, about the subjectivity or objectivity of development of history, Marx emphasizes the importance of human activities, while Engels holds the position of me chanical determinism, stressing the importance of following the objective rules. Based on evidence from the works by Marx and Engels, the author claims that the philosophy of Marx and Engels are basically the same and the claim “conflicts exist between Marx and Engels” does not hold water and is not true. The author also explains that Marx and Engels have basically the same ideas by referring to their cooperation in founding and explaining new theories.

Key words: Marx, Engels, difference, conflicts, same

中图分类号: