主管:教育部
主办:中国人民大学
ISSN 0257-2826  CN 11-1454/G4

《教学与研究》 ›› 2005, Vol. ›› Issue (7): 16-22.DOI:

• 当代中国社会发展研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

“现代性”批判的两种不同定向——论马克思资本批判与现代性哲学话语的基本差异

罗骞   

  1. 复旦大学哲学系, 上海200433
  • 收稿日期:2005-01-26 出版日期:2005-07-20 发布日期:2012-03-05

Two Orientations to Criticism of“Modernity”—— On basic Differences between Marx’ Criticism of Capital and Discourse of Modem Philosophy

LUO Qian   

  1. Department of Philosophy, Fudan University, Shanghai 200433, China
  • Received:2005-01-26 Online:2005-07-20 Published:2012-03-05

摘要: 文章认为当今的“现代性哲学话语”对现代性的批判主要是一种观念的意识形态批判,试图将启蒙精神和启蒙原则作为最内在的因素来探讨现代性的困境。而马克思以“资本”范畴将现代概念化,在历史唯物主义的理论基础上揭示了现代性存在论上的基本原则和基本建制,并由此批判资产阶级的现代性意识形态。然而,“现代哲学话语”没有充分理解马克思资本范畴的这种存在论意义,而是有意无意地将其指认为一种经济主义的还原论,错误地将马克思理论作为一种现代性的理论进行坚持或批判。马克思现代性批判的奠基性意义在这种错误的指认中无意地流失了。文章呈现了马克思在“资本”范畴之下展开的现代性批判同当今流行的“现代性话语”之间的基本差异,以突出马克思思想在现代性批判中的枢纽地位。

关键词: 现代性哲学话语, 历史唯物主义, 资本, 资本现代性, 存在论

Abstract: This paper maintains that criticism of modernity in discourse of modern philosophy today focuses mainly on the ideological side, which tends to consider the spirit and principles of enlightenment as the most internal aspects to account for the dilemma of modernity. When Marx criticized the capitalist modern ideology, the author reasons, he referred to the category of capital to conceptualize modernity, and interpreted the essential principles and construct of the modern existence theory in the light of historical materialism. However, discourse of modern philosophy failed to understand the meaning of Marxist category of capital, and then unconsciously, if not consciously, refers to it as an economic theory of reversion. While doing so, they consider Marxist theory a theory of modernity to adhere to or criticize. Consequently, the founding significance of Marx’ criticism of modernity gets lost. This article analyzes the basic differences between Marx’s criticism of modernity by referring to capital and the modern discourse that is so popular nowadays, and emphasizes the critical position of Marxist ideas in modern criticism.

Key words: discourse of modern philosophy, historical materialism, capital, modernity of capital, existence

中图分类号: