主管:教育部
主办:中国人民大学
ISSN 0257-2826  CN 11-1454/G4

《教学与研究》

• 西方思潮评介 • 上一篇    

评功利主义的代际正义理论

高景柱#br#   

  1. 天津师范大学政治与行政学院
  • 出版日期:2019-05-16 发布日期:2019-05-13
  • 基金资助:
    本文系国家社科基金重大项目“西方国别政治思想史”(项目号:13&ZD149)阶段性成果。

On Utilitarian Theory of Intergenerational Justice

Gao Jingzhu   

  1. School of Politics and Public Administration,Tianjin Normal University,Tianjin 300387
  • Online:2019-05-16 Published:2019-05-13
  • About author:高景柱,天津师范大学政治与行政学院教授(天津 300387)。

摘要: 代际正义理论是当代政治哲学中的一种重要理论,其中功利主义是分析代际正义理论的重要视角之一。功利主义的“不偏不倚”和“时间中立”理念中体现出来的平等主义底色,为人们分析代际正义理论提供了一个良好的起点。然而,无论侧重于“总体效用”的总体功利主义,抑或聚焦“平均效用”的平均功利主义,对代际正义理论的解释都是难以令人信服的,功利主义的代际正义理论面临着一种两难困境。它既可能无法容纳人们所必须担负的一些特殊义务,又可能对未来世代的利益进行不合理地“折扣”。

关键词: 代际正义 , 未来世代 , 功利主义 , 平等主义

Abstract: The theory of intergenerational justice is an important theory in contemporary political philosophy, of which utilitarianism is one of the important perspectives to analyze theory of intergenerational justiceThe egalitarian background embodied in the utilitarian concepts of impartiality and time neutrality provides a good starting point for people to analyze theory of intergenerational justiceHowever, regardless of the overall utilitarianism that focuses on overall utility or the average utilitarianism that focuses on average utility, the explanation of intergenerational justice is unconvincing, and the utilitarian theory of intergenerational justice is facing a dilemmaIt may not only be unable to accommodate some special obligations that people must undertake, but also may unreasonably discount the interests of future generations

Key words: intergenerational justice , future generations , utilitarianism , egalitarian